top of page
Search

PAT CONROY NO CURE FOR STUPID (regarding Ignorant comments about Sir Robert Menzies)

PAT CONROY NO CURE FOR STUPID (regarding Ignorant comments about Sir Robert Menzies) **Sir Robert Menzies was not a Nazi sympathizer or collaborator; claims labeling him a "Nazi appeaser" are selective, partisan exaggerations that ignore context, his actions as PM, and the broader historical reality of pre-WWII diplomacy.**


### The Recent Propaganda

In July 2026, Albanese government Defence Industry Minister Pat Conroy repeatedly called Menzies a “Nazi appeaser” while praising John Curtin, framing it as a choice between Labor’s strong defense stance and Liberal weakness. He doubled down despite backlash, citing a 1939 letter and pre-war views. This fits a pattern of Labor using history for partisan attacks on the Liberal founder amid defense debates. Historians and Menzies’ defenders (including the Robert Menzies Institute) describe such characterizations as “grubby smear[s]” or fallacious, cherry-picking isolated comments while ignoring his record.


### Context of Pre-War "Appeasement"

Appeasement was mainstream British Empire policy under Neville Chamberlain (and supported across much of the political spectrum, including initially by many in Labor and conservatives) after the horrors of WWI. Leaders hoped to avoid another catastrophic war by addressing German grievances from Versailles, buying time for rearmament. Menzies, as Attorney-General and later PM (from April 1939), supported this as official policy.


- **1938 Germany visit**: As a minister, Menzies toured Europe, including Nazi Germany. He privately admired aspects of German efficiency, discipline, and state devotion in letters (e.g., noting a “spiritual quality” and “magnificent” abandonment of some liberties for the state). He also criticized elements like church persecution and the “queer atmosphere.” These were observations from a fact-finding trip, not endorsement of Nazism or antisemitism. Contemporaries across democracies made similar mixed notes on fascist efficiency before full horrors emerged.

- **Munich Agreement**: Menzies backed Chamberlain’s 1938 deal, like most at the time. Post-Kristallnacht and further aggressions, views shifted.

- **1939 letter**: Days after Poland’s invasion (Sept 11, 1939), Menzies wrote privately to High Commissioner Stanley Bruce suggesting possible negotiations after Poland’s fall, hoping Hitler might offer terms to avoid total war. He weighed Australian lives heavily. By early October, as facts clarified, he supported continuing the war. This reflects a leader’s private doubts amid crisis—not unique, and not pro-Nazi.


These do **not** equate to sympathy for Nazism. Menzies condemned Hitler’s aggression publicly and privately in many instances. No evidence shows collaboration, funding, ideological alignment, or tolerance of Nazi crimes. Claims of admiration often stem from Communist Party or left sources amplifying outliers.


### Menzies Led Australia into War Against the Nazis

On September 3, 1939, Menzies declared: “It is my melancholy duty to inform you officially that... Australia is also at war” with Germany, aligning with Britain. He mobilized forces, created the Department of Supply and Munitions, passed National Security Acts, and prepared the economy. Australia committed troops to fight Nazis in Europe and North Africa under his government. He later supported the war effort in opposition.


This directly disproves “anything to do with Nazis.” Australia under Menzies fought them as part of the Allied effort.


### Similarities to Winston Churchill

Menzies and Churchill shared traits and a complex relationship, evolving into friendship:


- **Oratory and leadership style**: Both master orators with deep classical education, wit, and imperial loyalty. Menzies was often compared to Churchill in eloquence.

- **Imperialists and democrats**: Strong believers in the British Empire, monarchy, and liberal democracy against totalitarianism. Menzies succeeded Churchill as Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports.

- **WWII involvement**: Menzies visited Britain in 1941, joined Churchill’s War Cabinet meetings, and pushed for better Singapore defenses and Australian interests. They clashed on strategy (Menzies cautious on some commitments; Churchill bolder), but both prioritized defeating Hitler. Post-war, they bonded as elder statesmen. Menzies delivered tributes and supported Churchill’s legacy (e.g., Memorial Trust).

- **Post-war anti-totalitarianism**: Like Churchill’s Iron Curtain speech, Menzies was a staunch Cold Warrior against communism—attempting to ban the Communist Party, supporting alliances, and viewing Soviet threats seriously. Both saw fascism and communism as twin evils.


Menzies was no Churchill in wartime charisma or global role, but shared core values: resolve against aggression (once clear), democratic institutions, and Empire/Commonwealth ties.


### Defense Spending and Curtin Comparison

Labor contrasts often claim Curtin pushed harder for defense while Menzies underfunded it. Pre-1939, both sides grappled with Depression-era constraints and appeasement hopes. Menzies’ government increased munitions and supply efforts upon taking office and war declaration. Curtin opposed some overseas commitments early on, favoring home defense. Both contributed; reducing it to “Curtin good, Menzies Nazi-appeaser” is ahistorical partisan revisionism.


### Why This is Fake News/Misreporting

- **Selective quoting**: Out-of-context 1938 admiration or 1939 private musing ignores Menzies’ war leadership, condemnations of Hitler, and thousands of other statements.

- **Presentism**: Judging 1930s views by 1945 knowledge of the Holocaust and full Nazi evil. Many Western leaders (including Churchill pre-1939 shifts) hoped for peace.

- **Partisan weaponization**: Albanese-era Labor revives this for “progressive patriotism” and to own national security credentials, echoing older left critiques. It’s not rigorous history but smear.

- **No Nazi ties**: Zero evidence of sympathy for Nazi ideology, party, or crimes. Menzies was a classical liberal conservative who fought them.


Menzies remains Australia’s longest-serving PM for good reason: economic recovery post-WWII, stability, and anti-communism. The “Nazi appeaser” label is lazy propaganda that collapses under scrutiny of his full record. Churchill himself navigated similar pre-war ambiguities before becoming the lion of defiance—parallels in leadership under pressure, not perfidy. (Perfidy is a noun that means deceit, treachery, or a deliberate breach of faith and trust. It refers to an act of extreme disloyalty where someone betrays a confidence or breaks a promise they previously made. )

Pat Conroy
Pat Conroy

Pat Conroy minister for the department of stupid

 
 
bottom of page